On Tuesday, 16 December 2025, the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (EFRA) Committee convened for its final session before the Christmas recess. Chaired by Mr. Alistair Carmichael, the session provided a platform for a deep dive into the complexities of the UK’s marine environment, funding, and the delicate relationship between the government and the fishing industry.
The witness panel featured Dame Angela Eagle MP, Minister for Food Security and Rural Affairs, supported by DEFRA officials Gareth Baynham-Hughes and Mike Dowell. The discussion ranged from the "spatial squeeze" of our oceans to the controversial role of international scientific advice in setting quotas.
The Engagement Gap: Remote Policy vs. Port Reality
A recurring theme throughout the session was the perceived disconnect between Whitehall and the frontline of the fishing industry. Committee members highlighted feedback from fishers in Brixham, who described engagement with DEFRA as "remote and one-sided."
In response, Dame Angela Eagle defended the government’s approach, citing "integrated co-operation" with devolved nations and the constant presence of the Marine Management Organisation (MMO) at ports. While Gareth Baynham-Hughes noted that strategic engagement is primarily funneled through representative organizations, the Chair challenged this, arguing that direct contact with processors and exporters is essential for understanding how policies—such as Marine Protected Areas (MPAs)—actually function on the ground.
The "Spatial Squeeze" and a New Framework
As the race for offshore energy intensifies, the Minister acknowledged a "genuine spatial squeeze" in UK waters. The competition for sea space between fishing fleets, energy infrastructure, and military requirements has reached a tipping point.
"The Minister expressed receptiveness toward developing a 'sea use framework' to coordinate these competing interests, emphasizing her legal duty under the Fisheries Act 2020 to ensure both sustainability and the economic viability of the fleet."
Science, Quotas, and the ICES Debate
Perhaps the most contentious segment of the session focused on the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES). Industry figures have long argued that ICES advice is often outdated by the time it reaches the water.
The Cod Controversy: The Chair expressed frustration over ICES's initial recommendation for a total closure of North Sea cod—an option based on a "12-month recovery" window that the Committee deemed socioeconomically catastrophic.
The Outcome: Mike Dowell clarified that the zero-catch advice was merely one option. Following negotiations with the EU and Norway, a 44–48% cut was agreed upon instead.
Minister Eagle maintained that while she acknowledges fishers' frustrations, the government is obligated to act on the "best available science" provided by ICES to maintain sustainable stocks, even if the resulting compromises "please nobody."
Evolving Palates and Economic Support
The Committee also explored the shifting ecology of UK waters, noting a "huge bloom" in cuttlefish and octopus driven by rising sea temperatures.
| Topic | Key Takeaway |
| Domestic Consumption | The Minister noted that while the government cannot force consumers away from traditional white fish, it supports initiatives to encourage "adventurous" eating habits. |
| Seafish Levy | A planned levy increase was halted before the Minister took office, a joint decision that has since reduced Seafish’s operational capacity. |
| Coastal Growth Fund | The Minister signaled strong support for using this fund to create inshore opportunities and reserve quotas for young fishers through apprenticeship schemes. |
Looking Ahead
The session concluded with a focus on technical measures in UK waters. Despite criticism from fishers regarding the speed of implementation without consultation, Dame Angela Eagle defended the measures as necessary under the Trade and Co-operation Agreement to protect zero-catch species.
As the Committee adjourned for the holidays, the overarching message was clear: the path to a sustainable and profitable fishing industry requires balancing rigid scientific mandates with the lived experience of those on the quayside. The EFRA Committee will resume its work on 6 January 2026, beginning with an evidence session on South East Water.
The EFRA committee recently launched a survey to gather priorities for the new year. Running until 16 January, you can respond here.
